Even Experts and SMEs Need an AI Answer Coach

Adam Paulisick - CEO @ SkillBuilder.io

Don’t assume confidence or accuracy are better than differentiation

Questions and answers power so much of our lives that we often overlook their influence. Research shows a large portion of our verbal interactions—whether in sales pitches, job interviews, or even bedtime routines with children—revolves around exchanging questions and answers. It’s an intuitive yet crucial fact: clarity flows from well-asked questions, and transformation can hinge on a timely, well-crafted response.

But if questions and answers are so foundational, why do experts and subject-matter specialists (SMEs) still find themselves delivering confident yet forgettable answers rather than standing apart with truly differentiated ones? Why can’t deep domain thinkers push beyond abstracted or generic responses that are great sounding but virtually identical to what any competitor in the market could say (big or small)?  Differentiation is HARD and harder to think of on demand.

The Kryptonite to Growing Businesses: Accuracy Without Differentiation

Picture a mid-stage SaaS company that offers a cloud-based analytics tool. The leadership team has done its homework; they’ve nailed the core features, hammered out accurate product descriptions, and are confident in their market fit. Yet, during sales calls, prospective customers sometimes leave unimpressed because the answers to “Why should we choose you?” sound a lot like every other analytics platform out there. 

They’re not wrong or unprepared—just undifferentiated. That small but vital gap can cost deals, especially when prospects are bombarded with alternatives that sound nearly identical.

** HUGE WARNING TO FELLOW AI BUILDERS ** AI is almost always hard to differentiate in real-time if there is a lack of training, data, or context.  Don’t be surprised if far less competitive or helpful products create confusion on the surface, you are not alone, and we hope the below helps change this pattern.

Enter A Simple but Powerful Differentiation Matrix

To illustrate how differentiation is essential, let’s look at a simple 2×2 grid. On one axis is Confidence (low to high), and on the other axis is Uniqueness or Differentiation (low to high).

Low Differentiation High Differentiation
High Confidence Looks competent but blends into a sea of similar answers. Often forgettable in competitive markets. Stands out by highlighting unique angles or benefits. More memorable and persuasive. Can’t easily be replicated and can be the driving narrative to quickly get out of a bake-off sale.
Low Confidence Causes mistrust or confusion. Forgettable and unimpressive. Best case you are a discount or low cost player. Shows promise of originality but lacks conviction. Risk of getting dismissed or overshadowed or giving a prospect the feeling you are experimenting on them and not even with them.

It’s not enough for an answer to be factually correct. Unless it resonates as unique or special, it risks being drowned out by the noise of competitors who are just as confident, if not more so.

Why Founders, CEOs and Experts Struggle with Truly Differentiated Answers

Founders and industry veterans aren’t immune. In fact, many experience cognitive or psychological barriers that block them from crafting compelling, one-of-a-kind responses EVEN IF THEY KNOW THE CONTENT DEEPLY:

The Paradox of Choice
With deep expertise comes a vast pool of knowledge. Faced with a blank page or an open-ended question, even an expert can freeze while trying to decide which angle is “best.”

Cognitive Load
Experts often carry a wealth of details in their heads. Without structure or prompts, it’s overwhelming to select which subset of knowledge is relevant in the moment.

Einstellung Effect
Past success can foster reliance on well-worn tactics or familiar frameworks. When asked for a fresh angle, experts can struggle to adapt beyond their usual go-to explanations.

Expectation Bias
With a reputation to uphold, there’s pressure to always deliver perfection. That internal pressure can hamper creativity, leaving the answer more conservative than innovative.

Zeigarnik Effect
When the mind sees an “unfinished task” without clear structure, it can stall out instead of diving in. A blank slate provides no natural entry point.

Cues and Anchors
Experts perform best when guided by a nudge—a relevant hint, context, or example. Otherwise, it’s like rummaging through an entire library without a catalog.

Taken together, these forces can trap even the most seasoned professionals in the realm of “accurate but generic.”

So, what to do? It might be time to hire a Coach

Coaches—whether in sports, public speaking, or leadership—exist because outside perspective matters. Elite athletes invest in coaching despite already being at the top of their game. Top CEOs rely on executive coaches to keep them sharp. Numerous studies affirm that consistent coaching correlates with higher performance, reduced mental friction, and improved self-awareness.

Yet, many experts and founders shy away from coaches, fearing it implies incompetence. In reality, coaching amplifies strengths and addresses blind spots—everyone from a novice employee to a Fortune 500 executive can benefit.

Coaching provides structure, accountability, and fresh perspectives. It combats the blank-page syndrome by offering starting points, frameworks, or small nudges to guide deeper thought. Instead of swimming in infinite possibilities, an expert or founder can funnel expertise into something that resonates powerfully and uniquely.

Why an AI “Answer Coach” Changes the Sales Game

SkillBuilder.io extends the coaching principle to one of the most valuable currencies in business: a compelling, differentiated answer. This “Answer Coach,” powered by AI, steps into the conversation every time a founder, SME, or salesperson needs to craft or refine a response.

Here’s how it works:

  1. Context Gathering
    The Answer Coach asks contextual questions: Who’s asking? What are their priorities? How detailed should the response be? By narrowing the scope, you avoid the cognitive overload that comes with a blank slate.
  1. Prompting Differentiation
    The AI prompts reflection on what makes you unique, ensuring you break away from generic statements and instead highlight distinctive advantages.
  1. Evidence and Backup
    By scanning your knowledge base, testimonials, or case studies, the Answer Coach helps incorporate concrete evidence—shifting your answer from “Trust me” to “Here’s why this genuinely matters.”
  1. Conquering Psychological Barriers
  • It reduces choice paralysis by suggesting relevant answer frameworks.
  • It lowers cognitive load by sifting through large amounts of data.
  • It helps reframe standard solutions, battling the Einstellung Effect.
  • It clarifies context, so expectation bias doesn’t lead to overthinking.
  • It naturally provides anchors, bypassing the Zeigarnik Effect and blank-page dread.
  • It offers small cues—reminders, insights, examples—so you’re never stuck rummaging through mental files alone.
  1. Consistent Improvement
    Each time the Answer Coach is used, it learns. It collects feedback, monitors effectiveness, and refines the prompts. This iterative loop means it gets smarter about what resonates and continues to refine how you articulate your brand or product.

The result is a repeatable, systematic approach that can be used across an organization. Sales teams, marketing specialists, and even new hires can tap into the same resource. Instead of a handful of people possessing the “best” way to answer a critical question, everyone has access to an infinitely scalable, always-learning mentor.

The Future of Differentiated Communication

Imagine if every single inquiry—whether it’s a question from a high-stakes prospect or a curious new employee—was met with the most effective, unique, and well-supported response.

Over time, this doesn’t just benefit a single sales call or campaign. It builds a trove of enhanced, refined knowledge that can power thousands of interactions—from personal customer conversations to team-wide training sessions.

The idea of a personal coach for every employee used to be a luxury reserved for top executives. With AI, an “Answer Coach” scales at near-zero cost, ensuring that even the busiest founder or the newest intern can deliver on both confidence and differentiation.

SkillBuilder.io’s approach is proof that we don’t have to settle for accurate yet forgettable. With the right coaching and the right AI tools, every question becomes a chance to shine—and every answer a uniquely competitive edge.Just think about how much faster deals will close, how many less meetings you need, and the premium you can finally realize when prospects or partners finally see your value proposition with absolute clarity.

Additional Thoughts

Mar 14, 2024

Kloopify

Mar 14, 2024

Orita.ai

Mar 14, 2024

The Forbes Funds

Mar 14, 2024

BlastPoint

Mar 14, 2024

Piper Creative

Want  to know what we’re thinking?
Subscribe to Thoughts.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Stay Connected