Steel Sharpens Steel: Why Talking To AI Makes You Smarter

Adam Paulisick - CEO @ SkillBuilder.io

Echo chambers aren’t just a product of social media… they’re embedded in boardrooms, Slack channels, and even our own mental habits. When you only talk to people who think like you, your ideas go untested, your assumptions go unchecked, and your blind spots stay comfortably invisible.

Enter AI. Not as an oracle, but as a sparring partner. A frictionless, tireless challenger that can test your logic, surface missing variables, and push your thinking beyond your default reflexes. Talking to AI isn’t just productive, it's necessary to avoid a sea of sameness in everything you communicate about.

AI as Cognitive Resistance Training

When you engage deeply with an AI agent, especially one built for strategic reasoning, it functions like intellectual weightlifting. You stretch your mental model. You start to realize where you’re too vague, too biased, or too siloed in your perspective.

Instead of saying “that’s just how we do things,” you start asking, “why do we do it that way?” And that shift alone is where growth begins.

How to Prompt AI to Sharpen Your Thinking

If you want to escape your mental echo chamber, here’s a simple but powerful 3-step framework for prompting:

State your belief clearly — Give the AI a firm starting point to respond to.
Prompt: “I believe we should only invest in influencer marketing for Gen Z because it’s the only channel where we’ve seen traction.”

Add context you may be ignoring — Ask the AI to explore what you're missing.
Prompt: “Challenge this belief using data from overlooked audiences, alternative digital channels, or historical shifts in consumer behavior.”

Ask for the opposing argument—then your rebuttal — Build nuance by simulating both sides of the debate.
Prompt: “What would a skeptical CFO argue against this strategy, and how would I rebut that based on our last quarter’s performance?”

Before and After: How AI Expands Your Thinking

Before Talking to AI:

“We should double down on TikTok influencers for our product. Gen Z lives there, and it's the only campaign we’ve seen perform.”

After Talking to AI:

“While TikTok remains valuable, we’re likely missing long-tail gains from YouTube creators who index higher on credibility and retention. Also, email open rates have spiked in segments we haven't touched since 2022—there’s a reactivation play we’re ignoring. I’d propose testing 3 hybrid channels and mapping them to different parts of the funnel.”

From Self-Validation to Self-Interrogation

What changed? The AI didn’t give you a silver bullet. It made you see your blind spots. It challenged your overconfidence. It exposed the laziness of ideas that went unexamined too long. It helped you get out of your own head—and your team will thank you for that.

Steel sharpens steel. The best version of your thinking might be one conversation with an AI agent away.

Additional Thoughts

Mar 14, 2024

Kloopify

Mar 14, 2024

Orita.ai

Mar 14, 2024

The Forbes Funds

Mar 14, 2024

BlastPoint

Mar 14, 2024

Piper Creative

Want  to know what we’re thinking?
Subscribe to Thoughts.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Stay Connected